Illusions of Victory

September 28, 2009

There's No Strategy To Win in Afghanistan

By Douglas Macgregor

Douglas MacArthur is regarded as a great commander because he got some very important things right, most famously the Inchon landing. He also got some things wrong, such as his push to the Yalu River.

His catchy statement, "there is no substitute for victory," was also wrong, though not so wrong as the armchair strategists who quote it out of context. In fact, "victory" is often an illusion, a will-o'-the-wisp that can lead nations and armies deeper into the bog of history until they disappear.

Presidents Dwight D. Eisenhower and Ronald Reagan had the foresight to avoid the bog, to halt inconclusive military operations in Korea and Lebanon before they consumed America's strength. Such men are rare, and even more rarely honored for their actions. (Continue reading)

This article was published in Defense News, September 28, 2009 and is available in its entirety online.

Douglas Macgregor, COL, USA (Ret.), is a fellow at the Straus Military Reform Project and the author of Warrior's Rage: The Great Tank Battle of 73 Easting. COL Macgregor is one of 45 signatories to the Coalition for a Realistic Foreign Policy's open letter to President Obama, which urged the president to rethink U.S. objectives in Afghanistan.

Posted by coalition at September 28, 2009 11:12 AM

<< Who's Afraid of a Terrorist Haven? | Main | Afghanistan: The Proxy War >>


Email to a friend

Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Coalition Events

Coalition Newsletter

Sign-up for the Free Coalition Newsletter and be notified when we publish new statements and important information.

>> Sign-up Online

Coalition Statements

The Coalition for a Realistic Foreign Policy is a group of scholars, policy makers and concerned citizens united by our opposition to an American empire. The Coalition is dedicated to promoting an alternative vision for American national security strategy that is consistent with American traditions and values.

>> Letter to President Obama Regarding Afghanistan

>> The Perils of Empire
>> The Perils of Occupation
>> Ending the Israeli-Palestinian Stalemate

Featured Articles

New Afghan War Assumptions Must Be Weighed before a Surge
Afghanistan: The Proxy War
Illusions of Victory
Who's Afraid of a Terrorist Haven?
U.S. Must Narrow Objectives in Afghanistan
Withdrawal without Winning?
Doubting Afghanistan
Should the United States Withdraw from Afghanistan?
The War We Can't Win
United Colors of Democracy